218 & 220 S Clay St, Louisville, KY 40202

$2,100,000
Property Type: Multi Family Square Footage: 5,948 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 4,400 Status: Active
Current Price: $2,100,000 List Date: 4/10/2026 Last Modified: 4/10/2026

Overview

Description

Introducing The Holy Goat—a rare, design-forward hospitality asset in the heart of Louisville's vibrant NULU district. Originally constructed in 1843 as a church, this landmark property has been thoughtfully transformed into a fully turnkey, five-unit short-term rental experience that seamlessly blends historic architecture with elevated, modern design. Each suite is intentionally curated with its own identity and aesthetic—from the expansive three-bedroom, two-bath Fellowship Hall to a collection of one-bedroom and studio offerings—creating a layered guest experience that drives both demand and repeat stays. The interiors are striking, distinctive, and purpose-built to stand out in a crowded short-term rental landscape.

Supplements: Positioned just steps from NULU's award-winning restaurants, boutiques, and galleries, the location is as compelling as the asset itself. Additionally, the opportunity to expand to seven total units provides meaningful upside for increased revenue and scale. This is more than an income-producing property—it is a statement asset. A true trophy acq ...

Listing Details MLS# 1714001

General Listing Information

Office Exclusive?
No
Listing Price
2100000
Property Sub Type
Apartment
REO/Bank Owned/HUD
No
HOA Y/N
No
HOA Annual $
0

Location

Street #
218 & 220
St Dir
S
Street
Clay
St Suffix
St
Area
00-Central Downtown District/Old Louisville
County
Jefferson
State/Province
KY
Zip Code
40202
Deed Bk
10540
Parcel ID
04017D00250000
Pg #
0932
Subdivision/Condo
OTHER
Block
017D
Lot
0025
Directions
Market St to Clay St

Contract Info

Original List Price
2100000
Disclosure
No

Property Description

SqFt -Total Finished
5948
Above Grade Finished
5948
SqFt - Source
Other
First Floor Laundry
Yes
Garage Y/N
No
Basement Y/N
No
Total Units
6
Lot Size Dimensions
-
Lot SF
4400
Security Deposit
-
Age
183
Year Built
1843
Covered Parking
No
Term/Lease
Short Term Rental
# of Furnaces
Yes
# of Water Heaters
4
Separate Meters
Yes
Sold As-Is
No
M Struct Flood Plain
No
Below Grade Finished
0
Nonconform SqFt Fin
0
Above Grade Unfin
0
Below Grade Unfin
0
Sqft - Total Unfin
0
# Parking Spaces
0

1st Level

Total Units
3

More Information

2nd Level

Total Units
3

Cooling

# of HVAC Units
Yes
Central Air
Yes
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Yes

Architectural Style

Contemporary
Yes

Lot Description

Sidewalk
Yes

Utilities

Electricity Connected
Yes
Fuel:Natural
Yes

Water Source

Public
Yes

Sewer

Public Sewer
Yes

Construction

Brick
Yes

Roof

Shingle
Yes

Owner Pays

See Remarks
Yes

Tenant Pays

See Remarks
Yes

Heating

Forced Air
Yes

Patio and Porch Features

Patio
Yes

Exterior

See Remarks
Yes

Property Features

Architectural Style: Contemporary Construction: Brick Roof: Shingle Owner Pays: See Remarks Tenant Pays: See Remarks Exterior: See Remarks Patio and Porch Features: Patio Utilities: Electricity Connected; Fuel:Natural Water Source: Public Sewer: Public Sewer Heating: Forced Air Cooling: Central Air; Wall/Window Unit(s) Lot Description: Sidewalk
Listing Office: Lenihan Sotheby's Int'l Realty
Source MLS Verified
Last Updated: April - 10 - 2026
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of Metro Search, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than the site owner are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo or the Internet Data Exchange thumbnail logo and detailed information about each listing includes the name of the listing broker.
Search powered by FBS Products